Otego: Muddy River Dairy , Joshua and Karli Johnson, 63 Main Street, Otego NY 13825. phone: 607-988-0026, email: kjo23@ . Raw cow milk for sale. Herd is mixed including Brown Swiss, Jersey, and Holstein cows. Cows spend time inside and outside every day; fed a mixed diet grown mostly right on the farm. For large milk orders (more than 5 gallons), please call ahead. Milk is bottled fresh every day. $5 for a gallon and $ for a half gallon. Farm store is open seven days a week 10 am to 8 pm. We also have fresh eggs, sweet corn, produce in season, and baked goods on the weekends – including pies, cakes, breads, and cookies. Tours are available, but it’s best to call ahead and plan a time. The farm located right on Rt. 7 and easily reached by way of I-88.